Question:
dwayne wade,lebron james and kobe bryant are 3 top players in the nba right.......Shaq?
anonymous
2009-12-28 23:12:40 UTC
so if ppl say lebron is better than wade and kobe is better and lebron nd all that
why not someone ask shaq
i mean he's played with all 3 of them(currently playing with lebron james)
Fifteen answers:
?
2009-12-31 07:38:54 UTC
It's possible, but they were all at different times. Dwyane Wade was just beginning his career when he played with Shaq, so that wouldn't be fair. Kobe wasn't at the same intensity and Lebron has him now. It wouldn't be a fair comparison right now.
JA
2009-12-29 07:49:59 UTC
I don't think so.

When Shaq played with Kobe, KB24's too young. What is on Kobe's mind that time was to score, score, score. Now, Kobe's a complete player unlike the previous years especially when he was with Shaq when he was just scoring and scoring, doesn't care with his team mates. It's also without Shaq when Kobe scored 81 points against the Toronto Raptors. He did all of the damage and showed when Shaq was not around.



When Shaq played with D-wade, D-Wade was still young too. I think it was Wade's 2nd season and Flash just learning Stan Van Gundy's system. When Flash came back from an injury that made the Heat a 15-67 pingpong team and drafted Michael Beasley, Dwade finally showed up and became a better player, averaging 30 plus points per game. Without Shaq.



Finally, Shaq with Lebron? Lebron's not in his prime yet. He will score more, rebound more, pass more, and defend more as years pass and I do believe that Shaq will not be with Lebron when that time comes. Lebron maybe the MVP, but it's just because Lebron has the ball every time in the 4th.



Their best will be when they will be without Shaq and I do believe that Shaq will not be a proper gauge to know who was the greatest player between those three.
JussThatKid
2009-12-30 02:30:12 UTC
He will say Kobe are He will say "Well all three are the three best and i think that all three are Superstars" or make up some excuse to get out of saying Kobe is better but Lebron will be better



It is unfair to compare all three Kobe is going to overtime in his prime and and James is 2 or 3 years upcoming and wade is 1 to 3 years into his prime



It would be fair to compare LeBron Wade and Anthony but then again.... One of them have never been to the finals or a a type of MVP or with kobe it would be Kobe,A.I,Steve Nash????
baudkarma
2009-12-29 17:45:48 UTC
Because Shaq won't give you an honest answer. Neither will any other pro athlete. They will ALWAYS say that their current team/coach/teammates are the best they've ever played with. Just check out what Brett Favre had to say when he joined the Vikings. Or any baseball player after he's been traded or signed as a free agent. They want their new team and their new city to like them, and you don't get that by saying, "No, these guys suck compared to my old team."
anonymous
2009-12-30 02:07:07 UTC
Right now shaq would probably say D-WADE cuz he gotem a champion ship. How bout kobe gotem 3. But ever since shaq got traded he HATES kobe so most likely hel root for #3
anonymous
2009-12-29 13:45:22 UTC
Kobe is the best right now. but Kobe was not at his best when he played with Shaq, but shaq has played with wade and Lebon at THEIR best, Kobe since about 3-4 years ago until now is playing better than ever... so shaq can't really tell, but I can, Kobe is the best , period!
donuts1227
2009-12-29 15:20:34 UTC
well shaq also played with nash and stoudemire but u cant consider them since he never won a champ with them OR WITH LEBRON YET and also when kobe was with shaq he was young and dwade was 2nd year now with lebron he'll haveta say lebron because he was the most developed before playing with him and was already an mvp already and the others he played with were never except nash but he didnt even make the playoffs last year so that didnt count
Carina
2009-12-31 19:06:47 UTC
good question...
anonymous
2009-12-29 08:25:44 UTC
Um....Well Shaq did say Kobe is better then Lebron in febuary 2009... Now idk what he will say since hes playing with Lebron... He probably wont even say who he thinks is better now since he plays with Lebron.
antt
2009-12-31 03:06:07 UTC
he wont a championship with Lebron I have a feeling
hitwidtwis
2009-12-29 08:18:41 UTC
Shaq might say... Well, everybody is talking about him, so might as well play with him. But talentwise, Lebron can not win a championship. - hahahahahahahha!
anonymous
2009-12-29 22:33:24 UTC
he'll say lebron since hes playin with him. and if he is traded to another team like the blazers, hell say brandon roy is the best. rockets? tmac (lol). Magic? vince carter. WIzards? arenas.



i know this bittch.
JoshuaN3
2009-12-30 05:39:01 UTC
shaw is washedd up dude ahaha probably anyone close to that list RIGHT NOW is probably bosh dirk and durant who arent close ENOUGH. shaq?? uhmm not evenn
aslxda2
2009-12-29 07:22:25 UTC
you are right Mr. Olowokandi
footballa
2009-12-31 05:59:08 UTC
YEAH SON!!


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...