Best all time - Magic Johnson, Dr. J or Michael Jordan? If not one of these, who?

Question

Dr. J did it all before MJ came around, but didn't win the championships. Magic played all 5 positions to help the Lakers win an NBA Championship as a rookie! Jordan great defense, Magic greatest playmaker. Yes, Kareem Abul-Jabbar deserves to be included in the conversation just like Wilt Chamberlain.

Answer 1

it depends on what you mean by best of all time.



if i was starting a new team and had to pick a player the first i would pick is Magic Johnson



reason is Magic made the whole team better, you can put 4 below avg players with magic and you'll still have a good team, while with jordan or kobe they wont make the playoffs.



now if you are talking about individual performance i would say Kobe is the best of all time, because the competition jordan played against was much weaker then the competition in current era.

Answer 2

learn your history before you post, Dr. J has won 2 or 3 championshion in the old ABA before it folded so in essence he has won 2 championship and he did win a NBA championship in the NBA with the 76ers. But he is far from being called the greatest but I will say he is in the top 15 because if you look at his position some of greatest played small forward like Pippen, Bird, and Lebron.



Magic, well first of all Magic came into the NBA in the best position, Magic came into the Lakers team that was already a playoff team, this team had arguably the best center in the game at the time and perhaps one of the 2 best center to ever played the game . So Magic came into an idea situation





Jordan came into the Bulls team that has not been in the playoff for quite awhile, they did not have another star on that team and did not have a great coach. But with a little help he did end up with 6 rings, 6 finals mvps, and 5 league mvps etc etc etc and he is the only one of the top players in the entire history of the league to say that he did not lose in the finals. So my pick for the best ever is Jordan because Magic lost in the finals, Bird lost in the finals. Jabbar lost in the finals, Wilt lost in the finals, Russell lost in the finals, as well as Shaq, Kobe and Lebron.

Answer 3

I wouldn't put Dr. J in the 'best ever' argument. He's top 15, but I can't make an argument to put him any higher. He's not ever the best SF of All-time - the title belongs to the great Larry Bird.



I got Magic in my top 3, but Jordan is number 1.



My criteria for being the GOAT (greatest of All-Time)



1. Dominance on both ends of the floor (defense and offense)



2. Stats and their place in history



3. Accolades (MVPs, Finals MVPs, etc)



4. Rings (in perspective - Robert Horry has 7 rings, but he's not an All-Time great)



5. Intangibles such as impact, legacy, entertainment, clutch ability and leadership





Jordan passes all of these criteria with flying colours.



1. Led the league in scoring a record 10 times. Averages over 30 ppg for his career. Won the Defensive Player of the Year award. Led the league in steals 3 times. He's the best shot blocking guard ever.



2. 3rd All-Time in points, 1st All Time in points per game in both the Playoffs and the regular season. 2nd All-Time in steals. His stretch between 1987 and 1989 is perhaps the best 3 seasons of basketball by an individual player ever.



3. 5 MVPs (2nd All-Time), 6 Finals MVPs (1st All-Time), 14 x All-Star, 10 x All-NBA First team, 9 x All-Defensive First team, Rookie of the Year, Defensive Player of the Year.



4. 6 rings as the best player on the team in two 3 peats. Beat out legends such as Charles Barkley, Karl Malone, John Stockton and Magic Johnson. Never lost in the Finals.



5. Arguably the most impact on the game. Has an outstanding legacy. Maybe the most entertaining player in any sport ever. Incredibly clutch. Winner.

Answer 4

Larry Bird

Answer 5

Larry Bird, because he could play all 5 positions







Michael Jordan = Most Overrated Player of All Time





Hope this helps

Answer 6

Jordan and Magic. Not Dr. J

Answer 7

Dr. J was the best ever. Nobody could change the game with 1 play like he could is what Red Auerbach said, the Coach who won 8 NBA championships in a row,the man who coached Bill Russell, John Havlichek and other greats. Everything Jordan did, Dr.J did first!

Answer 8

MAGIC IN ROOKIE YEAR WITH ABDUL JABBAR OUT OF THE GAME IN 1979-80 SEASON PLAY THE FINAL AGAINST DR J AND BEAT HIM PLAYING 5 POSITIONS....

Answer 9

a million- M.J vs. Wilt Chamberlin? - Wilt grow to be enormously dang rapid and had some mad hops. Plus, there is not any way Jordan ought to furnish up him, he has too lots potential on Jordan. i think of Wilt would take it, yet i think of Jordan's potential equipment remains greater advantageous. 2- M.J vs. Magic Johnson? - MJ. Magic grow to be enormously on the threshold of Jordan in potential yet in a distinctive section...passing. it quite is one on one so as that's ineffective. 3- M.J vs. Kobe Bryant? - MJ - because of the fact he's greater effective than Kobe offensively (slightly) and defensively (probable significantly.) 4- M.J vs. Vince Carter - Vince Carter will go down as between the gamers who would have been large, possibly whilst solid as Jordan yet laziness and injury prevented it. MJ would kill him reason Vince can not play D. 5- M.J vs. Karl Malone - Karl Malone's form of play isn't any solid for a million on a million. He can not take his guy one on one. MJ wins. 6- M.J vs. Allen Iverson - Iverson certainly could be waiting to take this, however Jordan is a batter participant. purely because of the fact Iverson grow to be born to go one on one along with his guy. it quite is what he does and he's definitely solid at it. 7- M.J vs. Hakeem Olajuwon - Olajuwon is between the quickest centers to ever play and he certainly ought to deal with the ball and shoot 20 foot jumpers. i certainly think of Hakeem would take it because of the fact i do no longer think of Jordan ought to furnish up his placed up-up and his dream shake with Hakeem's length benefit. on the different hand, Jordan has slightly on him in quickness yet i think of Hakeem ought to stay in front of him. i'm gonna provide it to Hakeem yet narrowly. (however Jordan grow to be a marginally greater effective participant basic). 8- M.J vs. Dr. J - No contest. MJ. they're the comparable participant in common terms Jordan is greater effective. 9- M.J vs. Shaquille O'Neal - If its make it take it whoever gets the ball first wins reason neither can furnish up the different. Jordan's no longer solid adequate to provide up Shaq, Shaq's no longer rapid adequate to provide up Jordan.

Answer 10

is anyone able to tell me what is the right answer for this question?